Last month, the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) issued RIBO Guidance 007 – Referral Fee Guidance (the Guidance), which addresses RIBO’s expectations applicable to referral arrangements and marketing arrangements involving RIBO licensees. The Guidance defines what RIBO considers to be a referral fee, as opposed to insurance commissions, marketing fees and payments for lead generation.
This article summarizes the pertinent aspects of the Guidance, along with our commentary in the context of today’s insurance market.
Referral fees
The Guidance broadly defines a referral fee as a payment that meets all of the following criteria:
- A one-time payment (including monetary or non-monetary compensation) for the referral of a single consumer;
- Any payment to a person or company that recommended a potential client or business opportunity and is legally or contractually entitled to receive the payment; and
- A payment made regardless of whether the business is bound or the referral results in a successful business transaction.
It is an act of misconduct for a RIBO-licensed broker to pay or accept a referral fee to or from an unlicensed person, unless it fits within a narrow subset of exceptions set out in Regulation 991: General made pursuant to the Registered Insurance Brokers Act (Regulation). The exceptions are limited to persons who are (i) licensed as an insurance agent or broker under the laws of any jurisdiction; (ii) licensed to sell mutual funds under the laws of any jurisdiction; (iii) licensed as a real estate agent or broker under the laws of any jurisdiction; (iv) licensed as a mortgage broker under the laws of any jurisdiction; (v) engaged in the business of a financial planner; (vi) engaged in the business of providing financing for the payment of insurance premiums or (vii) engaged in the business of providing products or services that reduce insurance risk.
The Guidance requires RIBO licensees to be satisfied that the unlicensed person or entity providing the referral did not engage in insurance brokering activities as part of making the referral. This augments the existing regulatory obligations of RIBO licensees, as it necessitates ensuring that any unlicensed parties are not engaging in any solicitation or negotiation of insurance, insurance consultation or risk management services. Licensees must have robust controls in place to mitigate risk in this regard, both from a contractual and oversight perspective.
Consistent with their code of conduct, licensees are expected to disclose conflicts of interest and ensure there is written consent for the collection, use and disclosure of the client’s information. In addition, they must disclose whether the referral will increase the consumer’s cost of insurance and whether the licensee may receive or pay a referral fee.
Insurance commissions
The Guidance refers to section 403 of the Insurance Act (Ontario), which prohibits insurers, brokers and agents from directly or indirectly paying or allowing to be paid compensation or “anything of value” to a person without an insurance agent or broker license for placing or negotiating insurance on lives, property or interests in Ontario, noting that “insurance commissions are any compensation or anything of value paid to any person for placing or negotiating insurance or negotiating the continuance or renewal of insurance.” This statement aligns with section 403, which is aimed at precluding the remuneration of unlicensed agent activity. One of the underlying legislative purposes here, and in the provincial insurance legislation across Canada, is to protect the public from unlicensed insurance activity. The focus of section 403 is, appropriately, on the unlicensed party’s activities.
In contrast, the Guidance also states that RIBO considers referral fee, marketing fee or lead generation payments to be insurance commissions where compensation is tied to the number of policies sold; renewals; trailing/recurring fees; and/or premium volume. This expands the types of payment arrangements that could constitute “insurance commissions” and goes well beyond the prohibition in section 403, as the only criteria is whether the payment is tied to sales or volume. Critically, RIBO’s evaluation of whether a payment constitutes an insurance commission does not consider the unlicensed party’s actual activities – this raises the question as to the precise nature of harm that RIBO is seeking to address.
Marketing fees
The Guidance defines a marketing fee as “compensation paid for general advertising, sponsorship, promotion, or other marketing services.” RIBO’s position is that marketing services are aimed at creating broad awareness or to direct consumers to a brokerage, without the marketing party providing, receiving, transferring or using individual customer information that could assist with generating a quote or arranging insurance.
Advertising has become increasingly personalized and utilizes customer data immensely. Customers are increasingly accustomed to, and demanding, personalized, streamlined experiences when purchasing or renewing insurance, particularly in the personal lines space. Marketing partners will inevitably have access to customer data that could be helpful for generating insurance quotations or conducting a risk assessment on the prospective insured.
The Guidance goes on to state that RIBO licensees may pay third parties for marketing and advertising services only if the fee is in “no way connected to the successful placement, continuance or renewal of insurance.” Marketing and advertising fees must not be tied to connecting a specific consumer to a licensee unless the arrangement complies with the referral fee requirements in the Regulation. This is at odds with commercial reality. A fundamental objective of entering into marketing arrangements, whether in the insurance industry or otherwise, is to increase sales activity and revenue for a company as a direct result of marketing. For RIBO licensees, the success or efficacy of a marketing arrangement is ultimately measured by successful policy placement.
Marketing arrangements are tools with the potential to improve and expedite the customer experience in the context of insurance procurement, including in respect of closing the protection gap. Due to the manner in which these payments have been categorized by RIBO, the Guidance may impede potential innovation and the use of properly structured marketing arrangements in which there are no concerns with the fair treatment of customers in Ontario.
Fees paid to insurance aggregators
The Guidance also addresses payments to insurance aggregators, which are defined by RIBO as third parties that generate “leads” by gathering consumer information and working with insurers and brokers to provide quotes and price comparisons to consumers shopping for insurance online. RIBO states that providing personalized quotes for insurance is a regulated activity which requires an insurance agent or broker license. Accordingly, RIBO licensees are expected to ensure such entities are appropriately licensed prior to payment of any fee.
It is important to note that the activities of insurance aggregators, as described by RIBO, do not extend to negotiation or placement of insurance (i.e., the activities specifically referenced in section 403), yet payments to such entities will effectively constitute insurance commissions, according to RIBO.
Key takeaways
The Guidance narrows the ability for RIBO licensees to compensate unlicensed persons and characterizes a broad category of payments as insurance commissions. RIBO licensees and other insurance market participants in Ontario must carefully structure referral and marketing arrangements with unlicensed parties to ensure that such arrangements, and any compensation paid thereunder, comply with applicable legislation, regulations and the Guidance. Licensees should also ensure that they maintain robust documentation in their client files (including all disclosures provided to clients) to evidence continued compliance with such regulatory expectations.
Please do not hesitate to contact Marisa Coggin or a member of our Corporate and Regulatory Insurance team to discuss.